Judaica as Portable Antiquities in England and Wales

Barford, Paul

doi:0860-0007

Download

Title: Judaica as Portable Antiquities in England and Wales

Abstract:

This article examines the use of the database of the Portable Antiquities Scheme (PAS) for England and Wales, which records archaeological finds made by the public (particularly metal detector users). The PAS database is generally considered a valuable resource for archaeological research, but its use as such is rarely critically examined. In this case study, artefacts related to the specific material culture of the historically-attested Jewish community in Britain are examined as a potential source of archaeological information about a specific historical social group. The article highlights several challenges in interpreting records deriving from information received from collectors and hobbyists as a substitute for data recovered by archaeological methods. Several false leads and misinterpretations have been identified, and the lack of contextual information for the artefacts is especially problematic. The PAS records are of limited utility as a standalone source of evidence, and cannot lead to meaningful conclusions about Jewish lives in Britain. The artefacts primarily serve as material illustrations of existing written records rather than independent sources of information.

References:

Barford P. M. 2016. Portable Antiquities Collectors and an Alter Archaeology of Viking England. In: J. Popielska-Grzybowska, J. Iwaszczuk, B. Józefów-Czerwińska (eds.), Meetings at the Borders. Studies dedicated to Professor Władysław Duczko. Acta Archaeologica Pultuskiensia 5. Pułtusk, 31-36.
Barford P. M. 2020a. Artefact Collecting: Creating or Destroying the Archaeological Record? “Folia Praehistorica Posnaniensia” 25, 39-91.
Barford P. M. 2020b. Some Aspects of the Collection-driven Exploitation of the Archaeological Record in England and Wales. “Revista d’Arqueologia de Ponent” 30, 101-125.
Berlin A. 2011. Magen David. In: A. Berlin (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of the Jewish Religion (2nd ed.). Oxford, 463.
Bonsall J. 2019. Challenges of Working with Legacy Data from Detectorists: A Case Study in the Fabrication of Evidence. In: T. L. Sutherland, D. Shiels, G. Hughes, S. H. Sutherland (eds.), Conference Proceedings: Fields of Conflict, 2016; Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland. Dublin, 30-52.
Brown R. B., McCartney S. 2003. The Internal Exile of Medieval English Jewry. “The Medieval History Journal” 6(1), 55-74.
Egan G. 1994. Lead Cloth Seals and Related Items in the British Museum. British Museum Occasional Papers 93. London.
Egan G., Pritchard F. 1991. Dress Accessories, c.1150-c.1450. Medieval Finds from Excavations in London 3. London.
Harvey P. D. A., McGuinness A. 1996. A Guide to British Medieval Seals. Toronto.
Hessayon A. 2011. Jews and Crypto-Jews in Sixteenth and Seventeenth Century England. “Cromohs: Cyber Review of Modern Historiograph” 16, 1-26.
Mesler K. 2019. The Latin Encounter with Hebrew Magic. In: S. Page, C. Rider (eds.), The Routledge History of Medieval Magic. London, 85-98.
Marks K. 2014. The Archaeology of Anglo-Jewry in England and Wales 1656-c. 1880. Oxford.
Powell D. 2012. Those Jewish Plumbas. “Leaden Tokens Telegraph” 82 (March/April 2012), 1.
Scholem G. 1949. The Curious History of the Six-Pointed Star. How the “Magen David” Became the Jewish Symbol. “Commentary Magazine” 8, 243-251.
Słapek D. 1999.“Poszukiwacze” w Wielkiej Brytanii. “Archeologia Żywa” 1999(4/2), 44-47.
Elton S. F. 2011. The Bagseal Gallery. Source: http://www.bagseals.org/gallery/main.php. Available on-line 30.06.2023.
Kosher Food Lead Seal – Source: http://www.bagseals.org/gallery/main.php?g2_itemId=4621. Available on-line 24.10.2023.
Murawski I. 2015. Do poszukiwań powinna wystarczyć zgoda właściciela terenu. “Rzeczpospolita” 24.10.2015. Source: https://www.rp.pl/opinie-prawne/art11384621-do-poszukiwan-powinna-wystarczyc-zgoda-wlasciciela-terenu. Available on-line 30.06.2023.
van Oostens J. 2016. Nieuwkoop: loden Metaaldetector vondsten. Privately printed. Source: https://www.academia.edu. Available on-line 30.06.2023
Portable Antiquities Scheme Database. 1996-present. Source: https://finds.org.uk/database. Available on=-line 30.06.2023.