The communal and renewed kibbutz: ideology, management and institutional change

Sofer, Michael; Grossman, Ephraim S.; Grossman, David

doi:1642-4689

Download

Title: The communal and renewed kibbutz: ideology, management and institutional change

Abstract:

This study considers the roles of management and ideology in modifying the sustainability of communal systems. We approached this issue by discussing the major forces that shaped the planned kibbutz and the recent processes that have brought about its current transformation. Using a questionnaire-based survey we tried to reveal the relative importance that the members attach to traditional kibbutz values and their perception of the tension between the original ideology and the management strategies that have been imposed on the communal society by both external and internal forces. The findings indicate that pragmatism tends to prevail over ideology and communality has difficulty in functioning effectively in a highly complex and changing world. It points to the weakening of the communal system and to growing disengagement from principles of equality. However, the process and project of reshaping the kibbutz is ongoing.

References:

1. Andelson R. V., 1991, Commons without Tragedy: The Congruence of Garrett Hardin and Henry George, [in:] Andelson R. V. (ed.), Commons without Tragedy, Protecting the Environment from Overpopulation – a New Approach, London, Shepheard-Walwyn, pp. 27–43.
2. Ben-Rafael E., 1997, Crisis and Transformation: The Kibbutz at Century's End, Albany, State University of New York Press.
3. Ben-Rafael E., 2003, Report on the Kibbutz, Public Committee on the Kibbutzim Subject, Jerusalem (Hebrew).
4. Beteille R., 1994, La Crise Rurale, Que sais-je? Paris, Presses Universitaires de France.
5. Bijaui S., 2005, The Emergence of Regionalism in the Kibbutz Movement: The Case of the 'Valleys' Circle, Horizons in Geography, 63, pp. 133–163 (Hebrew).
6. Blomley N., 2005, Remember Property? Progress in Human Geography, 29 (2), pp. 125–127.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1191/0309132505ph535xx -
7. Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS), 2013, Statistical Abstract of Israel 2013, Jerusalem.
8. Cohen A., 2006, Why the Kibbutzim Will Stop Issuing Stocks in the Stock Exchange, Haaretz, The Marker June 7, 56 (Hebrew).
9. Degani O., 2006, The Regional Council as an Alternative Supporting System for the Changing Kibbutz, Horizons in Geography, 66, pp. 134–153 (Hebrew).
10. Discussions Team, 1991, The Kibbutz at the Turn of the Century: Crisis, Change, Continuity, Ramat Efal, Yad Tabenkin, First 3 meetings (Hebrew).
11. Discussions Team, 1992, The Kibbutz at the Turn of the Century: Crisis, Change, Continuity, Ramat Efal, Yad Tabenkin, Meetings 4, 5, 6 (Hebrew).
12. Edelman M., Roe J., Patton D., 1999, Land Use Conflict: When City and Country Clash, Dayton, OH: Kettering Foundation.
13. Gal A., 2011, From "We" to "Me": The Ideological Roots of the Privatization of the Kibbutz, [in:] Palgi M., Reinharz S. (eds.), One Hundred Years of Kibbutz Life: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, New Brunswick, Transactions, pp. 33–46.
14. Getz S., 1998, Winds of Change, [in:] Leviatan U., Quarter J., Oliver H. (eds.), Crisis in the Israeli Kibbutz: Meeting the Challenge of Changing Times, Westport, Praeger, pp. 13–25.
15. Getz S., 2009, Changes in the Kibbutz – 2008, Haifa Institute of the Research of the Kibbutz and the Cooperative Idea, University of Haifa (Hebrew).
16. Grossman D., Kark R., 2004, Common Pool Management: Implications for Israeli Settlements, Horizons in Geography, 60–61, pp. 99–107 (Hebrew)
17. Hardin G., 1968, The Tragedy of the Commons, Science, 162, pp. 1243–1248.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.162.3859.1243 -
18. Helman A., 1994, Privatization and the Israeli Kibbutz Experience, Journal of Rural Cooperation, 22 (1–2), pp. 19–32.
19. Hogeland J., 2004, How Culture Drives Economic Behavior in Cooperatives, Journal of Rural Cooperation, 32 (1), pp. 19–36.
20. Kibbutz Industries Association (KIA) internet site: http://www.kia.co.il/infoeng/about.htm
21. Lapidot A., Applebaum L., Yehudai M., 2000, From Protection to Competition: The Kibbutz in a Changing Environment, Ramat Efal, Yad Tabenkin (Hebrew).
22. Lapidot A., Applebaum L., Yehudai M., 2006, The Kibbutz in a Changing Environment – Between Survival and Preservation, Horizons in Geography, 66, pp. 7–27 (Hebrew).
23. McCarthy J., 2005, Rural Geography: Multifunctional Rural Geographies – Reactionary or Radical? Progress in Human Geography, 29 (6), pp. 773–782.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1191/0309132505ph584pr -
24. Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Planning and Development Authority, 2011, Economic Report on the State of Agriculture and the Rural Sector 2010 (Hebrew).
25. Morin S. R., 1996, Common Property and Exchange in a Natural Resource Management System: A Case Study from Aceh Province, Indonesia, Unpublished Ph.D Dissertation, University of Kentucky.
26. Mort J. A., Brenner G., 2003, Our Hearts Invented a Place: Can Kibbutz Survive in Today's Israel? Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
27. Netting R. M., 1993, Smallholders, Householders; Farm Families and the Ecology of Intensive, Sustainable Agriculture, Stanford, Stanford University Press.
28. Oakerson R. J., 1992, Analyzing the Commons: A Framework, [in:] Bromley D. W. (ed.), Making the Commons Work: Theory, Practice, and Policy, San Francisco, Institute for Contemporary Studies, pp. 41–59.
29. Ostrum E., 1990, Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Actions, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511807763 -
30. Ostrum E., 1999, Coping with Strategies of the Commons, Annual Review of Political Science, 2, pp. 493–535.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.polisci.2.1.493 -
31. Oved Y., 1993, American Communes: The Historical Experience in Agricultural Cooperatives in Transition, [in:] Csaki C., Kislev Y. (eds.), Boulder, Westview Press, pp. 383–392.
32. Palgi M., Orchan E., 2005, Public Opinion Survey in the Kibbutzim in 2005, Haifa, Haifa University, Kibbutz Research Institute (Hebrew).
33. Pauker A., 2011, The Early Roots of a Later Crisis – The Kibbutz Crisis of the 1980s and Its Roots at the Time of the Establishment of the State of Israel, [in:] Palgi M., Reinharz S. (eds.), One Hundred Years of Kibbutz Life: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, Transactions, New Brunswick, pp. 19–32.
34. Pavin A., 2011, Crisis, Social Capital and Community Resilience, [in:] Palgi M., Reinharz S. (eds) One Hundred Years of Kibbutz Life: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, Transactions, New Brunswick, pp. 59–71.
35. Palgi M., 2002, Organizational Change and Ideology: The Case of the Kibbutz, International Review of Sociology, 12 (3), pp. 289–402.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0390670022000041394 -
36. Palgi M., Reinharz S., 2001, The Kibbutz at One Hundred: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, [in:] Palgi M., Reinharz S. (eds.), One Hundred Years of Kibbutz Life: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, New Brunswick, Transactions, pp. 1–12.
37. Ravid S., 1994, Is the Kibbutz Undergoing a Value Change? Journal of Rural Cooperation, 22 (1–2), pp. 33–40.
38. Robinson G. M., 2004, Geographies of Agriculture: Globalisation, Restructuring and Sustainability, Harlow, Pearson.
39. Rosner M., Getz S., 1994, Towards a Theory of Changes in the Kibbutz, Journal of Rural Cooperation, 22 (1–2), pp. 41–61.
40. Rosolio D., 1999, Crises, Adjustments and Changes in the Kibbutz Movement, Tel-Aviv, Am Oved (Hebrew).
41. Runge F., 1992, Common Property and Collective Action in Economic Development, [in:] Bromley D. W. (ed.), Making the Commons Work: Theory, Practice, and Policy, San Francisco, Institute for Contemporary Studies, pp. 17–39.
42. Russell R., Hanneman R., Getz S., 2006, Demographic and Environmental Influences on the Diffusion of Change among the Israeli Kibbutzim, 1990–2001, Worker Participation: Current Research and Future Trends: Research in the Sociology of Work, 16, pp. 269–297.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0277-2833(06)16010-0 -
43. Schwartz M., 1995, Unlimited Guarantees: History, Political Economy and the Crisis of Cooperative Agriculture in Israel, Beer Sheva, Ben Gurion University Press, (Hebrew).
44. Schwartz M., 1999, The Rise and Decline of the Israeli Moshav Cooperative: A Historical Overview, Journal of Rural Cooperation, 27 (2), pp. 129–166.
45. Sofer M., 2009. Twenty Years of Change in the Fijian Periphery: The Case of the Kadavu Island, Fiji, Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, 30, pp. 343–357.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9493.2009.00374.x -
46. Sofer M., Applebaum L., 2006, The Rural Space in Israel in Search of Renewed Identity: The Case of the Moshav, Journal of Rural Studies, 22, pp. 323–336.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2005.10.004 -
47. Sofer M., Applebaum L., 2009, The Emergence of Farmers-Entrepreneurs as Local Development Agents in the Rural Space of Israel, Rural Studies, 20, pp. 107–125.
48. Sofer M., Grossman D., 2007, The Kibbutz in Search of a New Identity, Analele Universitatii Spiru Haret, Seria Geografie, 10, pp. 103–114.
49. Stevenson G. G., 1991, Common Property Economics: A General Theory and Land Use Applications, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511528361 -
50. Storm M., 2011. The Thai revolution: The Changes in Agriculture in the Kibbutzim and Moshavim of the Arava in the 1990s, [in:] Palgi M., Reinharz S. (eds.), One Hundred Years of Kibbutz Life: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, New Brunswick, Transactions, pp. 289–301.
51. Topel M., 2011, The Changing Composition of Kibbutz Elites, [in:] Palgi M., Reinharz S. (eds), One Hundred Years of Kibbutz Life: A Century of Crises and Reinvention, New Brunswick, Transactions, pp. 47–58.
52. Topel M., Ben-Rafael, E., 2006, Technocratic Leadership in the Kibbutz, Horizons in Geography, 66, pp. 28–43 (Hebrew).
53. Woods M., 2010, Rural, London, Routledge.