‘Schools of Hatred’ : The Essence of Totalitarianism in Jerzy W. Borejsza’s Approach

Ceran, Tomasz Sylwiusz (1983– )

doi:0001-6829

Download

Title: ‘Schools of Hatred’ : The Essence of Totalitarianism in Jerzy W. Borejsza’s Approach

Abstract:

Jerzy W. Borejsza regarded the term ‘totalitarianism’ as a helpful tool in describing the political systems in Nazi Germany, fascist Italy, and the Bolshevik/communist Soviet Union, but opted for restricted use of the term. Apart from the classical determinants of a totalitarian system, he believed that the mobilisation of hatred against the predefined ethnic/national, racial, or class enemy was essential to any totalitarianism. Rather than adding a new distinguishing feature of the totalitarian system, the Polish historian carried out a series of multi-aspect comparative analyses of its earlier-defined traits and characteristics. He has drawn a precise distinction between a totalitarian and authoritarian system. Not satisfied with apparent similarities, he tried to explore the issue more deeply, identifying different intensities of the phenomena specific to totalitarian systems. He stressed a gradation of totalitarianism in the different totalitarian systems, at the different stages of their functioning. To his credit goes the introduction in the historiography of the concept of ‘anti-Slavism’ and, as part of it, anti-Polonism, as essential traits of the National Socialist ideology. He opposed the simplifications tending to appear in broadly used terms, the attempts to ‘ideologise’ and ‘politicise’ the history, particularly in describing the communist totalitarianism. According to Borejsza, fascism, Nazism, and communism had once frequented the same school of totalitarian hatred and took there the same classes – but they were differently evaluated when it came to the finals.

References:

Borejsza Jerzy W., ‘Kilka uwag o autorytaryzmach i totalitaryzmach’, in Włodzimierz Mędrzecki (ed.), Społeczeństwo, państwo, modernizacja. Studia ofiarowane Januszowi Żarnowskiemu w siedemdziesiątą rocznicę urodzin (Warszawa, 2002).
Borejsza Jerzy W., ‘O autorytaryzmie można nieskończenie’, Historia i Polityka, 2–3 [9–10] (2010).
Borejsza Jerzy W., Antyslawizm Adolfa Hitlera (Warszawa, 1988).
Borejsza Jerzy W., Ostaniec, czyli ostatni świadek (Warszawa, 2018).
Borejsza Jerzy W., A Ridiculous Hundred Million Slavs: Concerning Adolf Hitler’s World-View, transl. from the Polish by David French (Warsaw, 2017).
Borejsza Jerzy W., Stulecie zagłady (Gdańsk–Warszawa, 2011).
Borejsza Jerzy W., Szkoły nienawiści. Historia faszyzmów europejskich 1919–1945 (Wrocław, 2000).
Carl J. Friedrich (ed.), Totalitarianism: Proceedings of a Conference Held at the American Academy of Arts and Sciences (Cambridge MA, 1954) [Polish ed.: id., Totalitaryzm. Materiały z konferencji zorganizowanej przez Amerykańską Akademię Sztuk i Nauk w marcu 1953 roku, transl. Sebastian Szymański (Warszawa, 2019)].
Dmitrów Edmund, Jerzy Eisler, Mirosław Filipowicz, Mariusz Wołos, and Grzegorz P. Bąbiak, Wiek nienawiści. Studia (Warszawa, 2014).
Kaczorowski Paweł, Marek Kornat, Joanna Lubecka, and Piotr Madajczyk (eds), Doświadczenie dwóch totalitaryzmów. Interpretacje (Warszawa, 2018).
Ryszka Franciszek, U źródeł sukcesu i klęski. Szkice z dziejów hitleryzmu (Warszawa, 1975).